How to disable IR on XSight / ARRX18G?
Moderator: Moderators
How to disable IR on XSight / ARRX18G?
I am using an ARRX18G to control my living room TV & HiFi constellation via a Marmitek PowerMid and IR Control Pro blasters. Unfortunately, the setup does not work reliably, apparently due to multipath interference from the ARRX18G's own IR emitter(s). It works quite well if I cover the remote's IR emitter end with my hand, but this is rather impractical for ordinary use. I have tried covering the emitter end with tape, but even thick black electrician's tape is not sufficient. The RF output of the remote can easily be disabled or enabled, but I haven't found any way to control the IR output. Is there any way (short of opening the case and physically disconnecting the emitter(s)) to disable the remote's IR output and use only RF?
-
The Robman
- Site Owner
- Posts: 21886
- Joined: Fri Aug 01, 2003 9:37 am
- Location: Chicago, IL
- Contact:
I was going to suggest electrical tape but I see you have already tried that. I can't imagine that IR is getting through the tape, so I wonder if you have a leak around the edges of the tape. Try this, put the tape back on the remote and then watch the remote using a cellphone camera to see if you can see where the IR is coming from. You can see IR when viewed using a digital camera.
Rob
www.hifi-remote.com
Please don't PM me with remote questions, post them in the forums so all the experts can help!
www.hifi-remote.com
Please don't PM me with remote questions, post them in the forums so all the experts can help!
Well, even if the tape is black in the visible light, it may still pass (maybe partially) IR light.
Try doing what Rob suggested with the phone's camera to check if it's the tape that is transparent to IR or if there's a leak around the tape.
I think that maybe some kind of a paper based tape would work better than a vinyl one.
Try doing what Rob suggested with the phone's camera to check if it's the tape that is transparent to IR or if there's a leak around the tape.
I think that maybe some kind of a paper based tape would work better than a vinyl one.
Marcin
Thanks for all the suggestions. If it weren't for the fact that even pointing the remote away from the equipment helps reliability, I would have though my interference theory was totally off-the wall.
I tried paper (masking) tape before moving on to electrical and duct tape (applied over the electrical tape!) However, still not as reliable as the hand over the end of the remote, even though my Galaxy's camera doesn't see any leakage, even in a darkened room. Right now I am trying a piece of thin cardboard. If that doesn't work, I'll try a thicker one. I haven't yet tried aluminum foil or nail polish. I am saving these as a last resort, as they seem trickier to apply without permanent effect on the remote.
Thanks again for the tips!
I tried paper (masking) tape before moving on to electrical and duct tape (applied over the electrical tape!) However, still not as reliable as the hand over the end of the remote, even though my Galaxy's camera doesn't see any leakage, even in a darkened room. Right now I am trying a piece of thin cardboard. If that doesn't work, I'll try a thicker one. I haven't yet tried aluminum foil or nail polish. I am saving these as a last resort, as they seem trickier to apply without permanent effect on the remote.
Thanks again for the tips!
Are you not using the RF base designed for the Xsight (ARRE433B or REX-433)? And if not, how does your repeater work if you block the IR from the remote?
I recommend a different approach. Get a REX-433 and stick the blasters directly on the the eyes of the equipment that's giving you trouble. I've never had any multipath issues using the REX as it relays the signals instantaneously.
The REX is a nice unit that comes with 6 blasters, each on very long wires.
https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R ... 3&_sacat=0
I recommend a different approach. Get a REX-433 and stick the blasters directly on the the eyes of the equipment that's giving you trouble. I've never had any multipath issues using the REX as it relays the signals instantaneously.
The REX is a nice unit that comes with 6 blasters, each on very long wires.
https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R ... 3&_sacat=0
-
The Robman
- Site Owner
- Posts: 21886
- Joined: Fri Aug 01, 2003 9:37 am
- Location: Chicago, IL
- Contact:
My recommendation would be aluminum foil held in place with electrical tape.
Rob
www.hifi-remote.com
Please don't PM me with remote questions, post them in the forums so all the experts can help!
www.hifi-remote.com
Please don't PM me with remote questions, post them in the forums so all the experts can help!
@mdavej
The Marmitek PowerMid decodes the RF from the ARRX18G and resends IR, ether directly or via IR extenders. In my case, the PowerMid is faced away from the controlled equipment and I am using the IR extender output of the PowerMid. The output goes to the IR input connector on my Onkyo receiver, which has a loopthru connector which then powers the corresponding Marmitek IR extenders pasted on or near the IR receivers of the other equipment to be controlled. However, the extenders are translucent and do not completely block extraneous IR, which seems to be causing the problem. It is also physically impossible to paste one directly on the IR sensor of my TV; the extender is attached to the base, a few centimeters away from the sensor.
@The Robman
Thanks for your usual cogent advice. 0.3 mm cardboard didn't work, but 1.7mm cardboard is doing a pretty good (if not perfect) job, at least better than the combination of duct tape and electrical tape. In the interest of a more esthetic solution, I will try a cardboard and aluminum foil sandwich.
The Marmitek PowerMid decodes the RF from the ARRX18G and resends IR, ether directly or via IR extenders. In my case, the PowerMid is faced away from the controlled equipment and I am using the IR extender output of the PowerMid. The output goes to the IR input connector on my Onkyo receiver, which has a loopthru connector which then powers the corresponding Marmitek IR extenders pasted on or near the IR receivers of the other equipment to be controlled. However, the extenders are translucent and do not completely block extraneous IR, which seems to be causing the problem. It is also physically impossible to paste one directly on the IR sensor of my TV; the extender is attached to the base, a few centimeters away from the sensor.
@The Robman
Thanks for your usual cogent advice. 0.3 mm cardboard didn't work, but 1.7mm cardboard is doing a pretty good (if not perfect) job, at least better than the combination of duct tape and electrical tape. In the interest of a more esthetic solution, I will try a cardboard and aluminum foil sandwich.
Aluminum foil and electrical tape didn't work so well. The cardboard and aluminum foil sandwich work a little better, and aluminum foil and duct tape work better still. Nonetheless, none of these is reliable, putting my hand over the remote's IR emitters works better.
At this point I see no alternative to opening the case, although I have read that I risk destroying it in the process. Any tips on how to do this would be welcome.
Another of my (newer!) Xsight Touch remotes already has a defective key, which I have read cannot be fixed at all.
I can no longer find any source of additional Xsight Touch remotes which ship to Switzerland (where I live). I found https://www.amazon.de/gp/offer-listing/ ... dition=new a Nevo C3 offered from Slovakia for EUR 149, but I would probably have to pay import duties in addition, and the supplier has only one rating.
What is the next best remote with RF, which I could program with RMIR?
At this point I see no alternative to opening the case, although I have read that I risk destroying it in the process. Any tips on how to do this would be welcome.
Another of my (newer!) Xsight Touch remotes already has a defective key, which I have read cannot be fixed at all.
I can no longer find any source of additional Xsight Touch remotes which ship to Switzerland (where I live). I found https://www.amazon.de/gp/offer-listing/ ... dition=new a Nevo C3 offered from Slovakia for EUR 149, but I would probably have to pay import duties in addition, and the supplier has only one rating.
What is the next best remote with RF, which I could program with RMIR?
This may help:
https://making.arantius.com/nevo-c2-rem ... ering-part
I just removed all the screws I could find, then tried to pry open at a corner, then slide a credit card around. You'll probably break at least the first clip, but you may be able to save the others using a flathead screwdriver to unlatch.
As you can see, the remote has 2 LED's - one at each corner. So whatever cover you use must cover the very edges as well. You may want to try black nail polish before opening the remote.
Unfortunately Xsight/Nevo is the last RF remote that UEI made, as far as I know. Would an IR repeater work for you in place of RF?
I'll look into how complicated/expensive shipping to Switzerland would be if I were to sell you one of mine and PM you my findings.
https://making.arantius.com/nevo-c2-rem ... ering-part
I just removed all the screws I could find, then tried to pry open at a corner, then slide a credit card around. You'll probably break at least the first clip, but you may be able to save the others using a flathead screwdriver to unlatch.
As you can see, the remote has 2 LED's - one at each corner. So whatever cover you use must cover the very edges as well. You may want to try black nail polish before opening the remote.
Unfortunately Xsight/Nevo is the last RF remote that UEI made, as far as I know. Would an IR repeater work for you in place of RF?
I'll look into how complicated/expensive shipping to Switzerland would be if I were to sell you one of mine and PM you my findings.
-
The Robman
- Site Owner
- Posts: 21886
- Joined: Fri Aug 01, 2003 9:37 am
- Location: Chicago, IL
- Contact:
If you open up the remote, wouldn't the goal be to remove the IR-LEDs rather than just cover them up?
Rob
www.hifi-remote.com
Please don't PM me with remote questions, post them in the forums so all the experts can help!
www.hifi-remote.com
Please don't PM me with remote questions, post them in the forums so all the experts can help!
@mdavej,
Many thanks for your extensive advice and offer of shipment to Switzerland!
Since you have already opened such a remote, perhaps you can tell me which side of the shell the tabs belong to. This will give me a better chance of releasing them without breakage.
I am reluctant to paint the front end:
Many thanks for your extensive advice and offer of shipment to Switzerland!
Since you have already opened such a remote, perhaps you can tell me which side of the shell the tabs belong to. This will give me a better chance of releasing them without breakage.
I am reluctant to paint the front end:
- Since there was leakage even with aluminum foil wrapped around the front end, I doubt that I will be able to cover it adequately with nail polish.
- I have 3 Xsight Touch units in differing states of (dis)repair and may need to rotate this one into an application where the IR is needed again.
-
The Robman
- Site Owner
- Posts: 21886
- Joined: Fri Aug 01, 2003 9:37 am
- Location: Chicago, IL
- Contact:
There is an IR repeater that works by replacing one of the batteries in the remote.
https://www.amazon.com/d/B000C1Z0HA
https://www.amazon.com/d/B000C1Z0HA
Rob
www.hifi-remote.com
Please don't PM me with remote questions, post them in the forums so all the experts can help!
www.hifi-remote.com
Please don't PM me with remote questions, post them in the forums so all the experts can help!